Wednesday, July 25, 2012

12-07-25 Time Line of Events: Moshe Silman - self-immolated, Israeli social protest activist - and the justice system of the State of Israel

In November 2009, Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner, formerly a Peace Court Judge, assumed a double-hat appointment in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court: Registrar and De Facto District Judge.  Shortly afterwards, he started appearing in cases related to the late Moshe Silman.
Following is the Time Line of Events, July 2008 - January 2010, of the cases related to Silman, based on records discovered so far:

  • The key finding is that the Appeal of Brenner's November 19, 2009 Decision in the hat of Registrar was eventually reviewed and denied on January 31, 2010 by Brenner in the hat of De Facto District Judge. 
  • Additionally alarming is the appearance, that the data in the remote terminals were edited in effort to convey the impression that Brenner was unaware of the related proceedings in the Supreme Court, which clarified the nature of his double-hat appointment.  The data in the local terminals provide evidence to the contrary. 
  • Various irregularities and discrepancies between data from the remote and the local terminals remain inexplicable.  The data accessed so far in both systems is partial at best, and the full records in this case are yet to be discovered.  Two requests to Inspect and to Copy are pending before Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner, one in his hat of Registrar, and the other in his hat of De Facto District Judge.
The case of the late Moshe Silman shows how a Person is required to protect his rights in the courts of the State of Israel today against the State of Israel, which took his property and source of livelihood. Conditions, which have been established in the courts of the State of Israel, following the implementation of new electronic Public Records over the past decade, amount to serious violation of the Human Right "to a fair and public hearing."
[] Emacs!  []
Moshe Silman

View as PDF: 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/101008706/
Tel-Aviv-Jaffa and Los Angeles, July 25 - Joseph Zernik, PhD, of Human Rights Alert (NGO) released a Time Line of Events, related to the late Moshe Silman, self-immolated Israeli social protest activist and the justice system of the State of Israel: [1] 1) Moshe Silman et al v Bituah Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch et al ( 13491/2008) - Original Complaint? - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court  [2,3]
  • July 10, 2008 - date of the first record under 1349/2008 - unsigned Decision by an unnamed person in the "Legal Department, Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court".
  • July 31, 2009 - unsigned Decision by The office of the Clerk of the District Court refused to receive for filing a Request to Inspect and to Copy under 1349/2008, since it did not exist.
2) Moshe Silman et al v Bituah Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch et al (1752-08) - Original Complaint? - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court  [2,3]
  • July 8, 2008 - is listed as the filing date of the Original Complaint under 1752-08.
  • October 8, 2009 - Registrar Ethan Orenstein's Decision, unsigned, indexed under both 13491-08 and 1752-08, notes that Response by Bituach Leumi failed to be filed in the court file, although it was apparently served on Silman's attorney.  Orenstein instructs the Attorney for Silman to file Bituach Leumi's Response in the Court.
3) November 1, 2009 - Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner, formerly Peace Court Judge, is appointed to a double-hat position in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court: Registrar and De Facto District Judge.

4) Moshe Silman et al v Bituah Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch et al (1752-08) - Original Complaint? - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court  [2,3]
  • November 19 (?), 2009 - the case was re-assigned (?) to Brenner in the hat of a Registrar (no normative documentation has been discovered so far of the Assignment/Re-assignment Procedures).
  • November 19, 2009 -  first appearance of a record by Brenner in the case - Decision - denying the Request for Waiver of Fees and ordering Dismissal of the Complaint.  The electronic Public Records fail to show valid court records for the Decision and the Protocol, and the Proceeding is not listed in the Calendar of the Court. The local terminal records explicitly state the the proceeding, presided by Hagai Brenner on that date "did not take place." The Protocol lists an unknown "Bracha" as Attorney for Bituach Leumi.  The records conflict on the date of issuance of the Order in the presence or the absence of the parties.
  • November 29, 2009 - The November 19, 2009 Decision was served (not yet delivered) on the Complainant
3) Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi Institute (10435/09) - Request for Leave to Appeal - in the Supreme Court of the State of Israel  [4]
  • December 28, 2009 -  Attorney for Silman files in the Supreme Court the Request for a Leave to Appeal the November 19, 2009 Brenner Decision.
  • December 29, 2009 -  Magistrate Judge Yigal Marzel of the Supreme Court issues the Order to Show Cause: Why the Appeal should not be dismissed, for having been filed with the wrong judicial authority?  The Order clarifies the double-hat nature of Brenner's appointment in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court.  Magistrate Judge Yigal Marzel finds that the November 19, 2009 Decision was issued by Brenner in the hat of Registrar, and that therefore, the Decision should be appealed before the the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court.
4) Moshe Silman et al v Bituah Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch et al ( 1752-08 and13491/2008) - Original Complaint - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court [2,3]
  • December 31, 2009 - Attorney for Silman files in the District Court Response on Bituach Leumi'
s Request to Dismiss for failing to pay filing fee.  In the Response, Silman asks Brenner to stay the execution of the November 19, 2009 Order and the Dismissal until the Request for Leave to Appeal, then pending before the Supreme Court, is decided. 5) Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch, Legal Department (6909-01-10) - Appeal of Magistrate Judge Decision - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court [5,6] 
  • January 6, 2010 - following the directives in the Order to Show Cause in the Supreme Court, Attorney for Silman files the Appeal in the District Court.
6) Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi Institute (10435/09) - Request for Leave to File an Appeal - in the Supreme Court of the State of Israel  [4]
  • January 12, 2010 - Judgment is issued by Magistrate Judge Yigal Marzel, dismissing the Request for Leave to Appeal in the Supreme Court.
7) Moshe Silman et al v Bituah Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch et al ( 1752-08 and13491/2008) - Original Complaint - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court  [2,3]
  • January 25, 2010 -  "Post-It Order" (in the local terminal) is issued by Brenner in the hat of Registrar, denying the Request to Stay and dismissing the Original Complaint. Brenner also notes that the Request for Leave to Appeal in the Supreme Court was filed with the wrong judicial authority.  The "Post-It Order" fails to be registered or be included in the electronic court file in a remote terminal.
8) Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch, Legal Department (6909-01-10) - Appeal of Magistrate Judge Decision - in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court [5,6]
  • January 31, 2010 - the Appeal of Brenner's Decision in the hat of Registrar is assigned to Brenner in the hat of De Facto District Judge. 
  • January 31, 2010 - Brenner in the hat of De Facto District Judge denies the Appeal, originating in Brenner's November 19, 2009 Decision in the hat of Registrar.  The record of the January 31, 2010 Decision/Judgement is missing from both local and remote terminals records.
The key finding from review of the records, so far discovered in the cases related to the late Moshe Silman, is that the Appeal of Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner's Decision in the hat of Magistrate Judge in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court was eventually assigned and denied by Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner in the hat of De FactoDistrict Judge.    
Additional causes for alarm:
  • The invalid Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner November 19, 2009 Decision and Protocol records in the Original Complaint, which fail to appear in the Calendar of the Court should be deemed suspect simulated court proceeding and court records;  likewise - the January 25, 2010 "Post-It Order" in the Original Complaint, denying the Request for Stay of the Dismissal, and the missing January 31, 2010 Judgment in the Appeal, both by Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner.
  • Overall review of the records suggests that the data, which appear in the remote terminals, were edited in effort to convey the impression that Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner was unaware of the proceedings in the Supreme Court, and of the issue of his double-hat appointment.  The data for the Original Complaint, which appear in a local terminal (particularly the January 25, 2010 "Post-It Decision"), make it clear that Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner was fully aware of the proceedings in the Supreme Court.  [7]
  • Various irregularities, missing records, and discrepancies between data from the remote and local terminals remain inexplicable.  [8]
Requests to Inspect and to Copy the Public Records in cases 1752-08 and 6909-01-10 are still pending before Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner of the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court, in the former case - in his hat of Registrar, and the latter - in his had of De Facto District Judge. [9]
"The case of the late Moshe Silman shows how a Person is required to protect his rights in the courts of the State of Israel today against the State of Israel, which took his property and source of livelihood," explains Dr Zernik.  Dr Zernik claims that the conditions, which have been established in the courts of the State of Israel, following the implementation of new electronic Public Record systems over the past decade, amount to serious violation of the Human Right "to a fair and public hearing." [10]
LINKS:
[1] 12-07-14 Moshe Silman sets himself on fire in a Tel Aviv social protest, leaves a letter
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289353/[2] 12-07-17 Moshe Silman v B ituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Barnch et al (1752-08 and  and 13491/2008 ) in the Tel Aviv District Court – electronic Public Records - remote terminal s
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289786/[3] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v B ituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Barnch et al (1752-08 and  and 13491/2008 ) in the Tel Aviv District Court – electronic Public Records - local public access terminal
http://www.scribd.com/doc/101008300/[4] 12-07-24 Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi Institute (10435/09) in the Supreme Court of the State of Israel  online public electronic records, as downloaded from a remote location
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100937934/[5] 12-07-24 Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch, Legal Department (6909-01-10)  Appeal of Magistrate Judge Decision in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court electronic Public Records - remote terminal s
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100914994/[6] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v Bituach Leumi-Tel-Aviv Branch, Legal Department (6909-01-10)  Appeal of Magistrate Judge Decision in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court  electronic Public Records - local terminal 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/101008615/[7]  12-07-22 PRESS RELEASE: Moshe Silman, Self-immolated Israeli Social Protest Activist, And the Justice System of the State of Israel (English)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100800832/[8] 12-07-24 PRESS RELEASE: Who Was Attorney for Bituach Leumi (Social Security) in Moshe Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court?
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100902177/[9] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v Social Security and State of Israel (1752/08 and 6909-01-10) in the Tel Aviv District Court - Requests to inspect and to copy court records (Heb + Eng)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100791012/[10] 12-06-04 Human Right Alert's Appendix to Submission; 15th UPR Working Group Session (Jan-Feb 2013) - State of Israel: Integrity, or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/82927700/ 
[11] 12-07-07 Biographical Sketch  Joseph Zernik, PhD 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/46421113/
_________
Joseph Zernik, PhD [11]
Human Rights Alert (NGO)
[]  
* The 2010 submission of Human Rights Alert to the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations, regarding the United States, was reviewed by the HRC professional staff and incorporated in the official HRC Professional Staff Report with a note referring to “corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California.”
* The 2012 submission of Human Rights Alert to the HRC regarding the State of Israel, titled "Integrity or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel," is scheduled for review in early 2013.
Human Rights Alert online[]   Flag Counter: 140http://inproperinla.blogspot.com/ 
http://inproperinla.wordpress.com/
http://human-rights-alert.blogspot.com/ 
Total Reads: 868,060 Followers: 1,547http://www.scribd.com/Human_Rights_Alerthttp://www.scribd.com/SeyagLizhuyotHaadam Total Reads: 50,147http://twitter.com/inproperinla
http://www.liveleak.com/user/jz12345 
Total Item Views: 664,803+304,012 
http://www.examiner.com/x-38742-LA-Business-Headlines-Examinerhttp://www.facebook.com/joseph.zernik 
Facebook Friends: 3,206_____________________________
Take away justice, then, and what are governments but great bandit bands?Saint Augustine, Civitas Dei (City of God,4.4)
_____________________________

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

12-07-25 Hello Mexico!


Last New Visitor

Mexico 
Visited 10 minutes ago

12-07-24 Hello Indonesia!


Last New Visitor

Indonesia 
Visited 22 minutes ago

12-07-24 Hello Germany!


Last New Visitor

Germany 
Visited 2 hours ago

12-07-24 Facebook Art: HR347

12-07-24 Who was attorney for Bituach Leumi in Moshe Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court?

Team A won decisively - three games in a row. The identities of the players on team A are yet to be discovered.
Emacs!  []
Moshe Silman

View as PDF:
Jerusalem and Los Angeles, July 24 -  Joseph Zernik, PhD, of Human Rights Alert (NGO), has filed a request with Attorney Yehezkel Reinhertz, of Frish Shperber Reinhertz & Co, Law Office, to disclose, whether the office was Attorney of Record for Bituach Leumi in Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al. [1]
In the opening lines of his last letter, Moshe Silman levels harsh charges against the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court.[2]
As noted in the request, filed today with Attorney Reinehertz, in the District Court, there are three Index Numbers associated with the Caption "Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al." - 1752/08, 13491/2008, and  6909-01-10.   In all three, Bituach Leumi prevailed.  However, court records do not provide information that would make it possible to identify, who  Attorney of Record for Bituach Leumi was in these cases.  Following suggestion by Attorney for the late Moshe Silman, today's request has been addressed to Attorney Yehezkel Reinhertz.

One of the early strong objections of the Israeli Bar Association to the new electronic record systems, which were implemented in the District Courts of the State of Israel over the past decade, originated in the unilateral decision of the Administration of Courts to delete the names of the Attorneys of Record of the parties from the new system. [3]
"In my experience, even a meeting of a student association, convened to decide on the annual beer budget, would not be deemed valid, if the names of the Officers of the association, present in the proceeding, were not listed in the minutes," says Dr Zernik.

The only Protocol, so far discovered under any of the three Index Numbers, is not an original court record, but a copy of an exhibit, which was filed by an attorney in another court.  In that Protocol, the Attorney of Record for Bituach Leumi is identified only as "Bracha" (a common female Hebrew first name, at times also a family name).

Falsification of a protocol of the Tel Aviv District Court by Deputy Presiding Judge Vardah AlSheikh, who handles some of heaviest corporate and banking regulation cases in Israel, is still a pending matter. [4]
In effort to coherently understand the events in the cases, related to the late Moshe Silman, in the Tel-Aviv-Jaffa District Court, Dr Zernik filed on July 22 Requests to Inspect and to Copy under two of the related Index Numbers - 1752/08 and  6909-01-10.  Pursuant to the Regulations of the Courts - Inspection of Court Files(2003), issued by then Minster of Justice Meir Shitrit, and also pursuant to a related decision by former Presiding Justice of the Supreme Court Dorit Beinisch, the Requests are now pending before Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner, who presided in both cases. [5]

However, the office of the Clerk of the District Court refused to accept for filing the Request to Inspect and to Copy under Index Number 13491/2008. [6] 

"
The refusal to accept for filing the Request to Inspect and to Copy under Moshe Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al (13491/2008), amounts to admission that some of the records in this case were originally filed under a non-existent Index Number.  Not that it was opened and closed, not that it was opened and then merged with another file, and not that it was lawfully sealed - it simply never existed," says Dr Zernik.

The deletion of the names of Attorneys of Record, the falsification of protocols, and false index numbers are only the tip of the iceberg of the fraud inherent in the design and operation of the new electronic record systems of the District Courts of the State of Israel, according to Dr Zernik. [7]
"The case of Moshe Silman shows how a Person is required to protect his rights in the courts of the State of Israel today against the State of Israel, which took his property and source of livelihood," Dr Zernik claims that the conduct of the Israeli courts, relative to the management of the electronic Public Records, amount to serious violation of the Human Right "to a fair and public hearing" of all the People of the State of Israel. [8]

LINKS:
[1] 12-07-24 Request filed with Attorney Yehezkel Reinhertz of Frish Shperber Reinhertz & Co Law Office re: representation of Bituach Leumi in Silman et al v Bituach Leumi et al.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100891747/[2] 12-07-14 Moshe Silman sets himself on fire in a Tel Aviv social protest, leaves a letter
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289353/[3] 09-09-30 Net Ha-Mishpat Eliminates Counsel Names From the Records_ Globes
http://www.scribd.com/doc/50622712/
08-10-30 Israeli Bar Asks to Stop Implementation of Net Ha-Mishpat "the situation is a catastrophe" _Globes
http://www.scribd.com/doc/50623267/ 
[4] 12-04-10 The Judge Alsheikh Affair – “Reconstructed Transcript” in the Tel-Aviv District Court _ Globe
http://www.scribd.com/doc/90686541/[5] 12-07-22 PRESS RELEASE: Moshe Silman, Self-immolated Israeli Social Protest Activist, And the Justice System of the State of Israel (English)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100800832/
[6] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v Social Security and State of Israel (1752/08 and 6909-01-10) in the Tel Aviv District Court - Requests to inspect and to copy court records (Heb + Eng)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100791012/
[7] 12-07-20 Zernik, J: "Integrity, of lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel", Data Analytics - in press
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100628792/[8] 12-06-04 Human Right Alert's Appendix to Submission; 15th UPR Working Group Session (Jan-Feb 2013) - State of Israel: Integrity, or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/82927700/ 
_________Joseph Zernik, PhDHuman Rights Alert (NGO)[]  
* The 2010 submission of Human Rights Alert to the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations, regarding the United States, was reviewed by the HRC professional staff and incorporated in the official HRC Professional Staff Report with a note referring to “corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California.”
* The 2012 submission of Human Rights Alert to the HRC regarding the State of Israel, titled "Integrity or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel," is scheduled for review in early 2013.
Human Rights Alert online[]  Flag Counter: 140http://inproperinla.blogspot.com/ 
http://inproperinla.wordpress.com/
http://human-rights-alert.blogspot.com/ 
Total Reads: 868,060 Followers: 1,547http://www.scribd.com/Human_Rights_Alerthttp://www.scribd.com/SeyagLizhuyotHaadam Total Reads: 50,147http://twitter.com/inproperinla
http://www.liveleak.com/user/jz12345 
Total Item Views: 664,803+304,012 
http://www.examiner.com/x-38742-LA-Business-Headlines-Examinerhttp://www.facebook.com/joseph.zernik 
Facebook Friends: 3,206_____________________________
Take away justice, then, and what are governments but great bandit bands?Saint Augustine, Civitas Dei (City of God,4.4)
_____________________________

Monday, July 23, 2012

12-07-24 Police Brutality in Anaheim, California

_____
Anaheim, CA, cops used shotguns to fire beanbag rounds toward men, women and children, and unleashed an attack dog on a woman with a stroller. Residents were upset an protesting a fatal officer-involved shooting that happened earlier in the day.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MST4RhWdlMQ
Photo: Anaheim, CA, cops used shotguns to fire beanbag rounds t

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=kqzoKY1CyAg

Police Shooting in Anaheim Leads to Violent Clash - RAW FOOTAGE & NEWS
www.youtube.com
ANAHEIM, Calif. - A police shooting that left a man dead led to a violent clash as angry witness threw bottles at offic

Photo

_____



Police brutality story heats up: Anaheim PD faces evidence-buying claims

Published: 23 July, 2012, 07:43
Edited: 23 July, 2012, 15:42
Image from twitter.com @EdJoyce. Video youtube courtesy of Reneebalenti
(4.1Mb)embed video

Witnesses to the fatal police shooting of an unarmed man in Anaheim, California say officers offered to buy up cell phone footage of the brutality that followed. The circumstances of the shooting are currently under investigation.
A few hours after shooting 24-year-old Manuel Diaz as he ran from police at around 4pm Saturday, officers unleashed rubber bullets and an attack dog on a crowd of witnesses – most of them women and children – who confronted police over the incident as they gathered evidence.
Diaz later died in hospital. Officials have yet to comment on what may have caused one of the officers to open fire.
The incident has resonated through the community, with demonstrations Sunday outside – and briefly inside – the Anaheim Police headquarters, as Police Chief John Welter prepared for a press-only news conference regarding the assault.
Demonstrators chanted "no justice, no peace" and "cops, pigs, murderers" as officers stood by.
And now that the story has gained national attention, the Anaheim PD claims the crowd of witnesses became unruly following the shooting, alleging that they set a fire at an intersection in the neighborhood, while others threw bottles and rocks at officers.
However, a news video posted to YouTube shows local CBS affiliate footage of what appears to be police storming a block filled mostly with women and children, many of them sitting in lawn chairs – with no fire in sight.
Local CBS reporter Jay Jackson confirms in the report that by shortly before 10pm Saturday, there was in fact a dumpster fire in the neighborhood after local residents formed a small protest, demanding answers from police. The Associated Press also now reports that dumpster fires were started on at least three occasions.  
In the YouTube video, police are clearly seen firing rubber bullets on a crowd of horrified women and children. Shortly thereafter a German Shepherd enters view, attacking a woman and her child and then a man sitting next to them.
Towards the end of the video, Jackson says that "at least four" people present during the fracas told him that officers on the scene offered to "buy" cell phone video footage of the incident from witnesses.
Anaheim police officials are refraining from commenting on the circumstances of the attack or its aftermath, as the incident is still under investigation.
The officer who shot Diaz has been put on desk duty.
Image from twitter.com @MikePrysner
Image from twitter.com @MikePrysner

Image from twitter.com @ReporterClaudia
Image from twitter.com @ReporterClaudia

12-07-23 Welcome To America

Police Shooting in Anaheim Leads to Violent Clash
Video
A police shooting that left a man dead led to a violent clash as angry witness threw bottles at officers who responded with tear gas and beanbag rounds to suppress the crowd, authorities said.   
Video Posted July 22, 2012
 

12-07-23 Hello Poland!


Last New Visitor

Poland 
Visited 5 minutes ago

12-07-22 Moshe Silman, self-immolated Israeli social protest activist, and the justice system of the State of Israel

In the opening lines of his last letter, Moshe Silman levels harsh charges against the District Court of Tel-Aviv-Jaffa.  Inspection of the online Public Records in the case, does not permit coherent understanding of events in the case in the District Court.  Request to inspect and to copy the entire records and registrations in the case was filed with Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner in the District Court.  Conduct of the courts of the State of Israel is central to the widening socio-economic gap over the past decade, the same way that corruption of the state and federal courts in the United States is central to the current crisis.
[] Emacs!  []
Moshe Silman

View as PDF: 
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100800832/
Tel-Aviv-Jaffa and Los Angeles, July 22 - request to inspect and to copy the Public Records in the case of self-immolated Israeli social protest activist Moshe Silman was filed by Joseph Zernik, PhD, of Human Rights Alert (NGO) with Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner in the Tell-Aviv-Jaffa District Court. [1] In the opening lines of his last letter, Moshe Silman levels harsh charges against the District Court. [2]
"Review of the online electronic Public Records does not permit coherent understanding of events in the case of Moshe Silman in the District Court," states Dr Zernik, "The online electronic Public Records are patently invalid." [3]
The electronic Public Records in this case, as they appear from a remote location and as they appear from the public terminal in the District Court:

  • Are unsigned;
  • On some, the name of the individual, who was the judicial authority, who issued the record fails to appear;
  • Some of the records are indexed under "CM 13491/2008", some are indexed under "CC 1752/08", and some under both index entries with no documented explanation.
  • The November 19, 2009 Decision and the November 19, 2009 Protocol fail to appear as original court records, but copies of records that were filed by an attorney in another court.  The Calendar of the District Court lists no court proceedings on that date.
Additionally, the electronic Public Records in this case, as they appear from a remote location and as they appear in the public terminal in the District Court are materially different:
  • An unsigned January 25, 2010 "Post-It Order" by Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner appears in the public terminal in the District Court, but fails to appear from a remote location.
  • Appeal of the Magistrate Judge Decision, and a related case in the Supreme Court of the State of Israel fail to be listed or mentioned in the electronic records of the original case from a remote location, but appear in the electronic records of the original case in the public terminal in the District Court.
The state of affairs of District Court's Public Records in the case of Moshe Silman highlights the fundamental corruption of the electronic Public Records of the courts of the State of Israel, following the implementation of new electronic record systems over the past decade.  The courts have developed and implemented with no public oversight multiple, inter-related but at times contradictory systems of electronic Public Records for each and every court file.  The People are denied access to most of these Public Records systems.  [4]
"The case of Moshe Silman shows how a Person is required to protect his rights in the courts of the State of Israel today against the State of Israel, which took his property and source of livelihood," explains Dr Zernik.  Dr Zernik claims that the conduct of the Israeli courts, relative to the management of the electronic Public Records, amount to serious violation of the Human Right "to a fair and public hearing."

It appears that the courts of the State of Israel have copied over the past decade the features of fraudulent electronic Public Records systems, which had been established in the state and federal courts in the United States a couple of decades earlier. [5,6]  According to the 2010 State of Israel Ombudsman's Report, two US corporations, IBM and EDS, were engaged in the project by the Administration of Courts of the State of Israel in violation of the law of the State of Israel. [7]
"Conduct of the courts of the State of Israel is central to the widening socio-economic gaps, the same way that corruption of the state and federal courts in the United States is central to the current crisis," claims Dr Zernik.

Pursuant to the Regulations of the Courts - Inspection of Court Files (2003) by then Minster of Justice Meir Shitrit[8] and related decision by former Presiding Justice of the Supreme Court Dorit Beinisch, [9] if the People would like to inspect the Public Records in the case and fully comprehend the events in this case in the court of Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner, one must ask Magistrate Judge Hagai Brenner's permission to inspect and to copy the records.  According to the office of the Clerk of the District Court, decision on the requests, filed today, may be entered within a few days.
LINKS:[1] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v Social Security and State of Israel (1752/08 and 6909-01-10) in the Tel Aviv District Court - Requests to inspect and to copy court records.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100791012/
[2] 12-07-14 Moshe Silman sets himself on fire in a Tel Aviv social protest, leaves a letter
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289353/ 
[3] 12-07-17 Moshe Silman v State of Israel (1752-08) in the Tel Aviv District Court – electronic public records s
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100289786/ 
[4] 12-06-04 Human Right Alert's Appendix to Submission; 15th UPR Working Group Session (Jan-Feb 2013) - State of Israel: Integrity, or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel
http://www.scribd.com/doc/82927700/  
[5] 12-05-24 Zernik, J:Design and Operation of the Electronic Record Systems of the US Courts are Linked to Failing Banking Regulation, Data Analytics - in press
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100623333/[6] [2] 12-07-20 Zernik, J: "Integrity, of lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel", Data Analytics - in press
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100628792/[7] 12-06-04 Human Right Alert's Appendix to Submission; 15th UPR Working Group Session (Jan-Feb 2013) - State of Israel: Integrity, or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel
http://www.scribd.com/doc/82927700/[8] 03-01-16 Takanot Batey Ha-Mishpat - Iyun Ba-Tikim (2003) // Regulations of the Courts - Inspection of Court Records (2003) (Heb +Eng)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/48770482/  
[9] 09-10-08 Israeli Civil Rights Association v Minister of Justice et al ( 5917/97) Chief Justice Dorit Beinish: The new case management system (Net Ha-Mishpat) would require restricting public access to court records _ Globes (Heb + Eng)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/50621508/ 
_________

Joseph Zernik, PhD
Human Rights Alert (NGO)[]  
* The 2010 submission of Human Rights Alert to the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations, regarding the United States, was reviewed by the HRC professional staff and incorporated in the official HRC Professional Staff Report with a note referring to “corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California.”
* The 2012 submission of Human Rights Alert to the HRC regarding the State of Israel, titled "Integrity or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel," is scheduled for review in early 2013.
Human Rights Alert online[]  Flag Counter: 140http://inproperinla.blogspot.com/ 
http://inproperinla.wordpress.com/
http://human-rights-alert.blogspot.com/ 
Total Reads: 868,060 Followers: 1,547http://www.scribd.com/Human_Rights_Alerthttp://www.scribd.com/SeyagLizhuyotHaadam Total Reads: 50,147http://twitter.com/inproperinla
http://www.liveleak.com/user/jz12345 
Total Item Views: 664,803+304,012 
http://www.examiner.com/x-38742-LA-Business-Headlines-Examinerhttp://www.facebook.com/joseph.zernik 
Facebook Friends: 3,206_____________________________
Take away justice, then, and what are governments but great bandit bands?Saint Augustine, Civitas Dei (City of God,4.4)
_____________________________WHAT DID THE EXPERT SAY ABOUT THE CURRENT FINANCIAL CRISIS?
*  
"I think it's difficult to find a fraud of this size on the U.S. court system in U.S. history," said Raymond Brescia, a visiting professor at Yale Law School who has written articles analyzing the role of courts in the financial crisis. "I can't think of one where you have literally tens of thousands of fraudulent documents filed in tens of thousands of cases." Reuters (Jan 22, 2012)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/79572282/* 
Foreclosure fraud: The homeowner nightmares continueCNN (April 7, 2011)
* 
About 3 million homes have been repossessed since the housing boom ended in 2006… That number could balloon to about6 million by 2013 Bloomberg (January 2011)
* 
"...a system in which only the little people have to obey the law, while the rich, and bankers especially, can cheat and defraud without consequences." http://www.scribd.com/doc/50753639/Prof Paul Krugman, MIT (2011)
_____________________________
WHAT DID THE EXPERTS SAY ABOUT THE JUSTICE SYSTEM IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY, CALIFORNIA?* 
"...judges tried and sentenced a staggering number of people for crimes they did not commit." Prof David Burcham, Dean, Loyola Law School, LA (2001)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/29043589/
* 
"This is conduct associated with the most repressive dictators and police states... and judges must share responsibility when innocent people are convicted."     Prof Erwin Chemerinsky, Dean, Irvine Law School (2001) http://www.scribd.com/doc/27433920/* "Innocent people remain in prison"* "...the LA Superior Court and the DA office, the two other parts of the justice system that the Blue Panel Report recommends must be investigated relative to the integrity of the system, have not produced any response that we know of..."LAPD Blue Ribbon Review Panel Report (2006)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/24902306 /_____________________________
WHAT DID THE EXPERTS SAY ABOUT THE JUSTICE SYSTEM IN CALIFORNIA?
* 
"...corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California." United Nations Human Rights Council Staff Report (2010)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/38566837/_____________________________
WHAT DID THE EXPERTS SAY ABOUT THE STATE COURTS IN THE UNITED STATES?
* 
"On July 26, 2010, Laurence Tribe, Senior Counsel for the United States Department of Justice, Access to Justice Initiative, delivered an important speech to the Conference of Chief Justices, challenging them to halt the disintegration of our state justice systems before they become indistinguishable from courts of third world nations."Prof Laurence Tribe, Harvard Law School (2010), per National Defender Leadership Institute (2010)
http://www.nlada.net/library/article/national_dojspeechto%20chiefjustice07-26-2010_gideonalert
_____________________________
WHAT DID THE EXPERTS SAY ABOUT THE CONDITIONS IN THE PRISON IN MONROE COUNTY, TENESSEE?* 
"What goes on there is more like gulags of centuries ago."ACLUhttp://www.scribd.com/doc/72546279/_____________________________
WHAT DID THE EXPERTS SAY ABOUT THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES?* 
"More than 100 law professors have signed on to a letter released today that proposes congressional hearings and legislation aimed at fashioning "mandatory and enforceable" ethics rules for Supreme Court justices for the first time. The effort, coordinated by the liberal Alliance for Justice, was triggered by "recent media reports," the letter said, apparently referring to stories of meetings and other potential conflicts of interest involving Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas among others."More than 100 law professors, as reported by the Blog of the Legal Times (February 2011) http://www.scribd.com/doc/49586436/_____________________________
WHAT DID CHIEF JUDGE OF THE US COURT OF APPEALS, 5TH CIRCUIT, SAY ABOUT THE US JUSTICE SYSTEM?
* 
"The American legal system has been corrupted almost beyond recognition..."
Chief Judge, US Court of Appeals, 5th Circuit, Edith Jones, speaking before the Federalist Society of Harvard Law School (February 2003)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/50137887/_____________________________
WHAT DID THE CHAIR OF THE SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE SAY ABOUT THE US JUSTICE SYSTEM?
* In a speech in Georgetown University, Senator Leahy, Chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee called for a "Truth and Reconciliation Commission" on the US Department of Justice.Transcript of Senator Leahy speech (2009)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/38472251/
____________________________ 

Sunday, July 22, 2012

12-07-22 משה סילמן ומערכת המשפט של מדינת ישראל


משה סילמן ומערכת המשפט של מדינת ישראל
בפתח מכתבו מטיח משה סילמן בשעותיו האחרונות האשמות כבדות כלפי בית המשפט המחוזי בתל-אביב-יפו.  בחינת הכתבים הציבוריים האלקטרוניים במקרה זה אינה מאפשרת לעמוד אל-נכון על מהות האירועים בבית המשפט בתיק זה.  בקשה לעיון בכלל הכתבים והרישומים בתיק הוגשה היום לרשם חגי ברנר בבית המשפט המחוזי. התנהלות בתי המשפט בישראל היא גורם מרכזי בהתרחבות הפער החברתי-כלכלי בישראל בעשור האחרון.
משה סילמן (מתוך דף הפייסבוק שלו)




    
תל-אביב, יולי 22 – ד"ר יוסף צרניק, מסייג לזכויות האדם (NGO), הגיש היום לרשם חגי ברנר בקשה לעיון בכלל הכתבים והרישומים בתיקים הקשורים למשה סילמן בבית המשפט המחוזי, תל-אביב-יפו. [[i]]  בפתח מכתבו מטיח משה סילמן בשעותיו האחרונות האשמות כבדות כלפי בית משפט זה. [[ii]]

"בחינת הכתבים הציבוריים האלקטרוניים המקוונים אינה מאפשרת לעמוד אל-נכון על מהות האירועים בבית המשפט במקרה זה,"  טוען ד"ר צרניק, "הכתבים הציבוריים האלקטרוניים המקוונים מציגים מסמכים שעל פניהם אינם יכולים להיחשב מסמכים משפטיים בני-תוקף". [[iii]]

כתבי ההחלטות בתיק,כפי שהם מופיעים במחשב ביתי, שמחוץ לבית המשפט, או מהמחשב לשימוש הציבור בבית המשפט עצמו:
-      אינם חתומים
-      על חלקם, שם הגורם השיפוטי שנתן את ההחלטה אינו נזכר כלל
-      חלקם מזוהים כרשומים תחת 'בש"א 13491/2008', חלקם מזוהים כרשומים תחת 'ת.א. 1752/08', וחלקם מזוהים כרשומים תחת שני מספרים אלה יחדיו.
-      ההחלטה והפרוטוקול של בית המשפט מיום ה-19 לנובמבר, 2012, אינם מופיעים ככתבים מקוריים של בית המשפט, אלא רק כעותקים שהוגשו על ידי משרד עורך-דין בבית דין אחר. יומן בית המשפט מציין שלא התקיים דיון בתיק זה באותו התאריך כלל.

בנוסף, הכתבים הציבוריים האלקטרוניים המקוונים במקרה זה, כפי שהם נראים ממחשב ביתי, שמחוץ לבית המשפט, שונים במהותם מן המסמכים הציבוריים האלקטרוניים במקרה זה, כפי שהם נראים מהמחשב לשימוש הציבור בבית המשפט:
-      "החלטה בפתקית"  של הרשם חגי ברנר, מיום ה-25 לינואר, 2010, מופיעה במחשב לשימוש הציבור בבית המשפט, אך אינה מופיעה כלל  בכתבים המופיעים ממחשב ביתי, שמחוץ לבית המשפט.
-      ערעור על החלטת הרשם בבית המשפט המחוזי עצמו, ופנייה בנידון לבית המשפט העליון מאוזכרים במחשב לשימוש הציבור בבית המשפט, אך אינם מאוזכרים כלל במסמכים וברישומים המופיעים מממחשב ביתי, שמחוץ לבית המשפט.

מצב הכתבים בתיק זה מצביע על הכשל הבסיסי במערכת "נט-המשפט": עם הטמעת "נט-המשפט" בבתי המשפט המחוזיים בעשור האחרון, יצרו בתי המשפט מערכות כפולות ומכופלות של כתבים לגבי כל תיק ותיק, השונות זו מזו במהותן, רובן מחוץ לגישת הציבור. [[iv]]

"מקרהו של משה סילמן מדגים כיצד אדם נדרש היום להגן על זכויותיו בבית דין של מדינת ישראל כנגד רשויות מדינת ישראל שנטלו את רכושו ומקור פרנסתו", מסביר ד"ר צרניק.  לטענתו, ניהול הכתבים האלקטרוניים של בתי המשפט בישראל בעקבות הטמעת המערכות הממוחשבות החדשות בעשור האחרון מהווה הפרה בוטה של זכות האדם "למשפט הוגן ופומבי" על ידי בתי המשפט בישראל.

"התנהלות בתי המשפט בישראל היא גורם מרכזי בהתרחבות הפער החברתי-כלכלי בישראל בעשור האחרון," טוען ד"ר צרניק.

על פי "תקנות בתי המשפט–עיון בתיקים",[[v]] ועל פי החלטתה של הנשיאה לשעבר דורית בייניש בנידון, [[vi]] אם ברצון הציבור לבחון את הכתבים הציבוריים במקרה זה, ולהבין אל-נכון את מהות האירועים בלשכתו של הרשם חגי ברנר, יש לבקש את רשות הרשם חגי ברנר לעיין בכתבים. על פי סגל מזכירות בית המשפט, ייתכן שהחלטתו של הרשם חגי ברנר בנידון העיון בכתבים במקרה משה סילמן תינתן כבר בימים הקרובים.


קישורים:
 [i] 12-07-22 Moshe Silman v Social Security and State of Israel (1752/08 and 6909-01-10) in the Tel Aviv District Court - Requests to inspect and to copy court records.
[ii] 12-07-14 Moshe Silman sets himself on fire in a Tel Aviv social protest, leaves a letter
[iii] 12-07-17 Moshe Silman v State of Israel (1752-08) in the Tel Aviv District Court – electronic public records s
[iv] 12-06-04 Human Right Alert's Appendix to Submission; 15th UPR Working Group Session (Jan-Feb 2013) - State of Israel: Integrity, or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel
[v] 03-01-16 Takanot Batey Ha-Mishpat - Iyun Ba-Tikim (2003) // Regulations of the Courts - Inspection of Court Records (2003) (Heb +Eng)
[vi] 09-10-08 Israeli Civil Rights Association v Minister of Justice et al ( 5917/97) Chief Justice Dorit Beinish: The new case management system (Net Ha-Mishpat) would require restricting public access to court records _ Globes (Heb + Eng)

Joseph Zernik, PhD
Human Rights Alert (NGO)
 
* The 2010 submission of Human Rights Alert to the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations, regarding the United States, was reviewed by the HRC professional staff and incorporated in the official HRC Professional Staff Report with a note referring to �corruption of the courts and the legal profession and discrimination by law enforcement in California.�
* The 2012 submission of Human Rights Alert to the HRC regarding the State of Israel, titled "Integrity or lack thereof, of the electronic record systems of the courts of the State of Israel," is scheduled for review in early 2013.

Human Rights Alert online
Flag Counter: 140
Total Reads: 868,060 
Followers: 1,547
Total Reads: 50,147
Total Item Views: 664,803+304,012
Facebook Friends: 3,206
_____________________________

Take away justice, then, and what are governments but great bandit bands?
Saint Augustine, Civitas Dei (City of God,4.4) 
_____________________________