Sunday, July 19, 2026

Appendix 11: Rachel Ben-Ari's Badge of Fraud #38 – "The Smoking Gun and the Black Flag" - two copies of the Initial Inventory Report

Appendix 11: Rachel Ben Ari's Badge of Fraud #38

Two copies of the Initial Inventory Report - "The Smoking Gun and the Black Flag" 

Appeal to Prof. Uri Sivan, President of the Technion, and Prof. Daniel Chamovitz, Chair of VERA, in re: Review of Rachel Ben-Ari's competence as Legal Counsel

Badge of Fraud #38 is materially different from all previous Badges of Fraud. It appears that it could stand on its own, perhaps with a minor investigation, as a proven case of fraud. Moreover, it implicates as partners in the fraud the top management of the Administrator General, including Haifa and the North District Manager, Attorney Tamira Alter, and the Administrator General in person - Attorney Ben Zion Feigelson. As the affair evolves, activity around the Haifa Court increasingly shows indicia of organized criminality.

Prepared by: Joseph Zernik, PhD, LLB.

Date: July 20, 2026.

In browser: https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/appendix-11-rachel-ben-aris-badge-of.html

PART I: PREFACE & ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK

1. The Historical Court Model in Israel, including the Probate Jurisdiction: The Mandate-Era Rules of Court, 1936

Historically, in Europe, the administration of wills and estates was controlled by the church from the medieval era until the 19th century. Later, it was under the jurisdiction of secular probate courts. The field has been known for generations to be prone to fraud and corruption, or at times sophisticated white-collar crime and predatory asset diversion. The beneficiaries are frequently ordinary individuals unfamiliar with complex legal and judicial procedures; on the other hand, the abuse was often perpetrated by professionals. 

In CA 153/77 Miriam Aloshvili v. Yosef Samuel, PD 32(1) 627, Presiding Justice Meir Shamgar explains that the model established in the Succession Law, 5725-1965, is based on close and strict judicial supervision of the estate administrator by the court. Shamgar describes in detail serious failures in the conduct of an estate administrator under the auspices of the lower court judge, and further explains:

The need for ongoing supervision and guidance by the court is a consequence of the distant historical experience, because originally, the role of the estate administrator was rife with rampant abuses.

The fundamental court system, which was established under the British mandate, followed the model of the English common law courts, found in most English-speaking nations. Such a model is based on the two arms of the court: The Judicial Arm and the Clerical/Ministerial Arm of the Court jointly operating through a system of checks and balances [see, I. Scott Messinger, ORDER IN THE COURTS: A History of the Federal Court Clerk's Office (2002) The Federal Judicial Center, 2002]. 

The  Judicial Arm is charged with adjudication, and benefits from immunities for actions that are part of adjudication. The Clerical Arm and, in particular, the Clerk of the Court is personally charged with the custody of all records and registers of the court. Those register, the Books of Court [ספרי היסוד של בית המשפט] were eventually fixed: The Index of All Cases, the Calendar of the Court, the Docket Books, the Judgment Book, the Appointment Book.  

These books were kept in the office of the Clerk of the Court, and it was prohibited to take them out. They were available for public inspection at any time during the Office of the Clerk of the Court's opening hours. Judgments had to be produced in two copies: one for the court file and the other glued into the Judgment Book. The process of entering the Judgments into the Judgment Book included the stamping with the Seal of the Court and the signature of the Clerk of the Court or a Deputy.

Appointments of Estate Administrators, Receivers, and Legal Guardians were treated similarly to Judgments, but the appointment records were glued into the Appointment Book.

All papers, both pleadings by the parties and orders by the judges, had to go through the Office of the Clerk, which held the exclusive authority to enter them into the registry of the appropriate file, while registering the papers in the Dockets.

Naturally, being in charge of the filing system and the custody of the court files and the Books of Court, the Clerk of the Court was also the Head Notary of the Court, or Prothonotary. The Clerk of the Court delegated the authority to authenticate court records, "True Copy of the Original," to Deputies.

.
 

Images | Left: In some counties in the U.S., the County Clerk, who also serves as the Chief Clerk of all the County Courts, holds the title of Prothonotary. Right: The Prothonotary Warbler is a small bird found in marshes in the southeastern United States. Its name refers to its colors, similar to those of the gown worn by a medieval Clerk of the Court.

*** 

Under the Rules of Court, 1936 (from the British Mandate for Palestine period), the English common law court model was established in Palestine. Therefore, all appointments of Estate Administrators had to be glued into the Appointment Book  - the Probate Register. The integrity of the system resulted from the independent functions of the two Arms of the Court: The Judge had to hear the case and sign an Appointment record. A copy of the Appointment record would go to the Clerk of the Court, who would examine, sign it and enter it into the Probate Register.

 

Rule 4 (Care of registers and records): "The officers responsible for the proper maintenance of the registers and records of the Courts shall be the officers in charge of the respective registries..."

 

Rule 11 (The Probate Register): "In all Courts having jurisdiction to issue grants of probate or letters of administration or to make declarations of succession there shall be maintained a register to be known as 'The Probate Register'..."

 

 There were auxiliary institutions, some going back to the Ottoman period, and the autonomous status given then to the various religious groups. 

 

2. The Succession Law, 5725-1965, and Establishing the Guardian General Administration

The British system underwent a major revision in the Succession Law, 5725-1965, to make it more resistant to fraud. Beyond the Office of the Clerk, an entire administration was built to supervise the Succession and Estate Administration matters, and it was combined with the office that administers the property of refugees - the Guardian General and Director of Inheritance Affairs.

The law established a specific authentication chain, aimed to make it more resistant to tampering and easier to supervise to make the system more resistant to imposters and thieves:

     1. When filing the initial pleading in the Request to Appoint an Estate Administrator, the filer must pay a specific fee to the Office of the Clerk of the Family Court and another fee to the Guardian General. The fee to the Guardian General establishes the registration of the court action as one that the Guardian General is following, and in which he is listed as a Respondent. 

   2. Once the request to appoint an Estate Administrator process is complete, again, there are parallel actions in the office of the Clerk of the Court, and the Office of the Guardian General.

          (a) The Clerk of the Court receives the Decree Appointing an Estate Administrator, closes the request to appoint an administrator file, and opens an Estate Administration file, in which the Decree Appointing an Estate Administrator is the first document, and in which all records pertaining to Estate Administration are filed. In this court file, an Officer of the Court, designated "Estate Administrator," is registered. The  "Estate Administrator" files requests for instructions in this court file. The supervision by the Guardian General is exerted on this court file. The estate funds are distributed from this court file.

      (b) The Guardian General receives from the Clerk of the Court service of a copy of the Decree Appointing an Estate Administrator. It triggers the opening of an Estate Administration Supervision file with the Guardian General.

   3. During its tenure,  the Estate Administrator files with the Guardian General (but not the Office of the Clerk of the Court) the Initial Inventory Report, the Periodic Financial Reports, and the Final Inventory Report.  Until 2023, the Guardian General was charged with inspecting all the records of the Estate Administrators. When necessary, the Guardian General had broad investigative authority and could easily obtain court orders if there was a need to remove Estate Administrators and take over the Estate Administration.

  4.  At the end of his/her tenure, the Estate Administrator files a financial report and a Final Estate Inventory [פרטה] with the Guardian General. Report of completing the Estate Administration work is typically required for the Court releasing the administrator and determining his/her fees. 

3. Revoking the notarial authority of the Clerk of the Israeli Supreme Court, 2002

  

On March 7, 2002, Clerk of the Supreme Court Shmaryahu Cohen died inside the courthouse  of a sudden heart attack. Some outlets reported that it was during a ceremony after hours. Some rumors said that he was fired on that day. It was rumored that there was some dispute between him and Supreme Court Presiding Justice, 

Regardless, upon his death, the certification "True Copy of the Original, Clerk of the Court, Shmaryahu Cohen" which appeared on all Supreme Court judicial records, disappeared. In its place, the disclaimer appeared "This version is subject to editing and phrasing changes." The disclaimer remained the permanent feature of Supreme Court judicial records until 2018. 

What the change in the footnote represented was the loss of the notarial authority of the Clerk of the court, and direct access to the justices to enter decisions in the court files. In fact, it amounted to abandoning the traditional model of the English courts with its two arms.

In a 2013 submission to the UN Human Rights Council, Dr. Zernik showed that such changes were accompanied by a wave of "fabrications" - what appeared to be after the fact changes to judicial records. 

In 2018, Dr. Zernik sent a request to Supreme Court Presiding Justice Esther Hayut for the disclaimer to be removed. Hayut granted his request and he received a thank you note from her bureau.

4. Initiating intensive development of Net HaMishpat, 2003-2007

The idea, or the need to switch to paperless courts had been considered since the 1990s. However only in 2003 the Administration of the Courts initiated the intensive development. By 2007, a beta version was up and running. It means that the general architecture and key features of the system were all determined and developed under the tenure of Aharon Barak as Presiding Justice of the Supreme Court and his protege' Boaz Okon as Director of the Courts.

Of note, the Israeli Administration of the Courts is an affiliate unit of the Ministry of Justice, and not by chance. The affiliation was created as a deliberate interpretation of the Separation of the Branches of Government. Therefore, the entire project of development and implementation of Net HaMishpat was funded through the Ministry of Justice. Each of the Justice Ministers since 2003 should be held under Individual Ministerial Responsibility for Net HaMishpat. However, it appears that a succession of Justice Ministers didn't exert even the appearance of oversight. 

5. Revoking the Rules of Court, 1936, and promulgating of the Courts Regulations (Office of the Clerk) - 2004

Development of Net HaMishpat had to generate interesting questions related to designing the detailed specifications of Net HaMishpat. Unfortunately, we will never know what these questions were, and how they were addressed. The entire project was conducted below the radar. 

In 2004, the British Rules of Court, 1936, which provided great detail about the way the Office of the Clerk must run, were revoked and replaced by the Courts Regulations (Office of the Clerk), 5765-2004, which said close to nothing about the operations in the Office of the Clerk, authorities and permission in handling court records.

Automated System [Mechanized System] 

 5. Any provision of these regulations shall be executed within the automated system of the courts and by electronic means, mutatis mutandis [with necessary adaptations], if so directed by the Director of the Courts. 

Therefore, the missing regulations need to be found in the code of Net HaMishpat, as directed by the Director of the Courts. 

We do know that the project was now driven by the new model for court operations, developed starting 2002 in the Israeli Supreme Court. To whit, the 2004 initial version of the new regulations never mentioned the Clerk of the Court. However, a year later, an amendment recreated the office:

Copies of Documents 

6A. The Clerks of the Courts are authorized to certify that a copy of a court record is a true copy of the original in the court file. 

Meanwhile, in the European Union 

During the same years, the member States of the EU were launching similar projects. However, here the approach was different:   

On September 18, 2002, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe adopted Resolution Res(2002)12, in which it established  the CEPEJ (European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice).Notable contributions were made by Dr. Dory Reiling, a retired Dutch judge, who had become a leading European expert on the subject, Marco Fabri and Francesco Contini, first through the European Commission–funded JEDI (Judicial Electronic Data Interchange in Europe) and later through CEPEJ.

In 2002-2005, Reiling and her colleagues established the framework:

  1. CMS Code = Procedural Rule: Software pathways enforce procedural rules; therefore, CMS design is a constitutional issue, not merely an IT or administrative one.

  2. Governance: Judicial IT must be validated and controlled under strict constitutional rules, not unreviewable executive/vendor discretion.

  3. Registry Integrity: Without formal specifications, independent validation, and non-repudiable audit logs, an electronic court registry loses its legal validity and destroys public trust.

 


 

authentication anchor was materialized in a system of absolute, transparent physical control. The rules explicitly mandated that the court's administrative core be controlled by the Clerk of the Court, who was responsible for the maintenance of court records and registries, and accordingly, authorized to certify their authenticity. Therefore, the records and sub. be subject to unyielding clerical custody. To establish the personal authority and accountability of the Clerk of the Court for the integrity and validity of records, the rules mandated the following:

administration, legal systems historically erected rigorous, physical authentication barriers to prevent the illicit diversion of assets through the introduction of simulated estate administrators.


The procedural mechanics were absolute: an appointment of an estate administrator derived its validity not from a piece of paper carried by an attorney, but from the mandatory entry within the official ledger under the direct oversight of the Clerk of the Court. This centralized, transparent, and non-negotiable paper record effectively neutralized institutional duplicity; the Office of the Clerk could not maintain a double standard or track hidden files, because the ledger represented a singular, unalterable baseline of truth open to public inspection.

2. The 2004 Digital Transition: The Unconstitutional Origins of "Code is Law"

In 2004, this historic framework of transparency was systematically dismantled to pave the way for the computerized case management system known as "Net HaMishpat" (The Net of Justice). Under the direction of Presiding Supreme Court Justice Aharon Barak and Justice Minister Tommy Lapid, the legacy paper safeguards were replaced by the Regulations of Courts (Clerks in Courts and Labor Courts), 2004.

Crucially, Regulation 5 of the 2004 regulations introduced a sweeping delegation of power: 

Automated System

5. "Every provision of these regulations shall be executed within the automated system of the courts and by electronic means, mutatis mutandis, if the Director of the Courts has so directed.

מערכת ממוכנת

5. "כל הוראה מתקנות אלה יש לקיים במערכת ממוכנת של בתי המשפט ובאמצעים אלקטרוניים, בשינויים המחויבים, אם הורה כך מנהל בתי המשפט.

This regulation effectively granted the Director of the Courts—a sitting judge—unilateral authority to adjust and substitute statutory court procedures to match computerized code. This delegation was fundamentally unconstitutional, violating the core principle of the separation of powers by allowing the judiciary to promulgate its own operational regulations without transparent oversight. It codified the dangerous doctrine of "Code is Law," completely hidden from the public eye.

This opaque approach stood in sharp contrast to contemporaneous global standards. Between 2002 and 2005, European Union institutions published extensive policy blueprints on building court Case Management Systems (CMS), explicitly warning that the transition to electronic courts was an issue of the highest constitutional concern that requires strict public oversight, absolute transparency, and democratic participation. In Israel, this warning was entirely ignored.

3. The Modern Automated Safeguard and Its Deliberate Evasion

To compensate for the elimination of physical ledgers, the modern framework established by the Succession Law, 1965 and the Succession Regulations, 1998 created a digital authentication loop. Under this framework, the Office of the Clerk is statutorily mandated to autonomously transmit (serve) any validly executed "Decree for Appointment of Estate Administrator" (Form 10 in the Regulations) directly to the Administrator General (Official Receiver / "Apafch") via integrated electronic channels.

The Administrator General cannot legally initiate an estate supervision file unless it receives this automated electronic service from the court system. This structural barrier ensures that no private attorney can unilaterally insert themselves into an estate without a validated, system-generated judicial mandate.

In the current matter, because the court system never issued an automated electronic service of a valid Form 10, the Office of the Clerk did not recognize any appointment. Instead, Deputy Clerk Keren Peles merely received and filed documents submitted by Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari under standard party designations, exposing the fact that no official court-sanctioned estate file was ever launched.

4. The Shift from Subtle White-Collar Manipulation to Coercive Process Simulation

White-collar fraud in judicial settings typically relies on "elegant," imperceptible procedural maneuvers, designed to keep the target unaware until the asset diversion is irreversible. In the instant matter, upon the immediate opening of Case No. 11650-06-24, the primary pleadings submitted by Attorneys Rachel Ben-Ari and Yoav Salomon were immediately identified by the lawful heir as structurally defective, constituting a prima facie declaration of intent to conduct proceedings for appearance's sake. Because the Israeli legal community appears in denial of the existence of such conduct, Dr. Zernik defined it pursuant to the offense in the Texas Penal Code, Article 32.48 — Simulating Legal Process.

Having their initial strategy instantly compromised by rigorous legal exposure, the legal actors were forced to abandon subtle manipulation and pivot to brutal tactical coercion. Merely forty-eight hours after the initialization of the proceedings, the actors filed an aggressive motion seeking to entirely strip the lawful heir of his autonomous legal personality under the equity law doctrine of "Cy Près" ("approximate performance")—a legal argument that is entirely nonsensical in this context, executed under the assumption that Dr. Zernik would be incapable of figuring it out.

Revoking the recognition of a person's autonomous legal personality is a severe legal act. Both the judge and the attorneys had to know that it could be done only pursuant to the strict protective procedures prescribed in the Legal Capacity and Guardianship Law, 1962 and corresponding regulations. Furthermore, this conduct violates absolute international prohibitions against the arbitrary stripping of legal personality, as codified under Article 6 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 16 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) (ratified by Israel in 1991, effective 1992).

5. The Standard of Deceit [Tarmit] and Judicial Misconduct

Consequently, this conduct constitutes a severe act of Misrepresentation and Frivolous Argument, in direct violation of Rule 34A of the Israel Bar Rules (Ethics), 1986. Given the intended outcome, which was fully realized, this act constitutes Fraud upon the Court, Deceit under Serious Circumstances, and Perversion of Justice on the part of the attorneys.

On the part of Judge Hila Gurevitz, this conduct constitutes Fraud upon the Court, Perversion of Justice, Deceit, Breach of Trust, Judicial Misconduct, and an Abuse of Discretion [Ultra Vires]. First and foremost, this represents an act of Tarmit (Civil Deceit) on the part of Judge Gurevitz. The standard of proof required to establish this civil deceit is far from "Beyond Reasonable Doubt"; pursuant to established case law, it sits above a mere Preponderance of the Evidence, at the standard of Clear and Convincing Evidence.

This was far from being an isolated incident. The first instance of such conduct by Judge Hila Gurevitz against Dr. Zernik occurred a year and a half earlier, merely a month after his mother passed away. On January 15, 2023, Judge Gurevitz entered court file AP 1829-06-10—a file lawfully assigned to a different judge, Judge Revital Baum—and entered an offending decision that was intentionally withheld from service to this day, regardless of repeat requests. Dr. Zernik had no prior interaction with Judge Gurevitz, and didn't even recognize her name. In fact he had nothing to do with the Haifa Court in the previous 6 years. The January 15, 2023, incident demonstrates that Judge Hila Gurevitz was acting as a targeted sabotage directed by external actors. The most plausible suspect was Hila Gurevitz's best friend - Judge Esperanza Alon [see Appendix 3]

Therefore, the historic precedent established by Presiding Justice Shimon Agranat in the Qadi of Lydda Ruling (CA 26/66 Taher Ibn Muhammad Hamad v. The Attorney General, PD 20(3) 57) applies directly to her:

"A judicial act tainted by fraud on the part of the judge... deprives the judicial authority at its core, and therefore the exemption [from criminal liability for a judicial officeholder] does not apply to such a judicial act." 

מעשה השפיטה שהיה נגוע בתרמית מצד השופט...יש בו כדי לשלול את הסמכות השיפוטית מעיקרה ולפיכך אין הפטור [מאחריות פלילית לנושא משרה שיפוטית] תופס במעשה שפיטה כנ"ל.

Accordingly, because her judicial acts were infected by civil deceit, all her judicial acts in relation to Dr. Joseph Zernik should be held void not voidable, and her  judicial immunity from criminal indictment must be revoked. The emerging picture points directly to indicia of organized crime operating within the court information systems.

PART II: FORENSIC ANALYSIS OF EXHIBIT #11 / APPENDIX #1

English Translation of Court Notice – Page 1

___________________________________________________________________________ 

In the Family Court                                 Case No. 11650-06-24 – Secondary                                                                             File in the Estate of the Deceased

Haifa  

In the Matter of: The Estate of the Deceased Rivka Zernik, z"l, ID 000645846

In the Matter of:

      Uri Zernik

      Attorney Yoav Salomon - has not filed a Power of Attorney to this day. 

                               - v - 

  1. Yosef Zernik                                            —     Respondent 1

    Pro Se

  2. Dror Zernik

    By Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari (Bar-Rav-Hai)    — Respondent 2

  3. Counsel for the Attorney General, Haifa — Respondent 3

Subject: Notice to the Office of the Clerk Regarding:

  1. Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and the Administrator General: The Smoking Gun and the Black Flag.

  2. Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and the Powers of Attorney Purportedly Obtained Through Fraud in Accordance with the August 28, 2023, Estate Distribution Agreement.

Summary: Respondent 1 hereby submits a notice to the Office of the Clerk regarding: 1. Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari and the Administrator General: The smoking gun and the black flag, 2. Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari and powers of attorney she purportedly obtained through fraud in accordance with the August 28, 2023, Estate Distribution Agreement. Instant Notice does not constitute a motion for a judicial decision; it is submitted for the sake of proper order and the completeness of the matters documented in instant case file, and is therefore exempt from court fees. Instant Notice does not constitute a "lawsuit," or anything remotely close to it. In the event that the registration of instant Notice is rejected for one reason or another, the Court is requested to strictly adhere to the statutory provisions concerning the lawful rejection and documentation of such a rejection.

English Translation of Court Notice – Page 3

  1. The following morning, June 25, 2024, Judge Hila Gurevitz or someone on her behalf coded the "motion" as – "Granted."

  2. The rest is clear; one can figure it out.

Conclusion: 11. The Court is requested to record this notice to the Office of the Clerk regarding: (1) Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and the Administrator General: The smoking gun and the black flag, 2) Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and powers of attorney she purportedly obtained through fraud in accordance with the estate distribution agreement dated August 28, 2023. This notice does not constitute a motion for a judicial decision; it is submitted for the sake of proper order and the completeness of the matters documented in instant case file, and is therefore exempt from court fees. This notice does not constitute a "lawsuit," or anything remotely close to it. In the event that this notice is rejected from registration, for one reason or another, the Court is requested to strictly adhere to the statutory provisions concerning the lawful rejection and documentation of such a rejection.

Dated: June 24, 2024

Appendices:

  • No. 1: Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and the Administrator General: The Smoking Gun and the Black Flag.

     

  • No. 2: Atty. Rachel Ben-Ari and powers of attorney she purportedly obtained through fraud in accordance with the Estate distribution agreement dated August 28, 2023.

Signed,

Yosef Zernik, PhD, LLB, Respondent 1

 

 /

Images | Left: Page 1 of the perverted document, claimed to be the Initial Inventory Report, which was mailed to Dr Zernik by Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari. Right: Page 1 of the same document, which was emailed to Dr Zernik by the Guardian General, who had received it from Rachel Ben-Ari.


/

Evidentiary Analysis of the Submission Bypass

:
  1. Circumvention of Systemic Controls: Because the court system never transmitted a valid electronic Form 10 to the Administrator General, there was no digital file open to receive documents. To bypass this automated validation gatekeeper, the actors generated an off-system paper document and manually walked it into the physical office.

  2. The Manual Verification Proof: The dark photocopy, physical staple punctures, and manual ink stamp "RECEIVED" (rather than a system-generated electronic confirmation) mathematically prove an off-system insertion. This manual entry was executed because the central computer system would have rejected the unverified "Psikta".

  3. Deliberate Removal of the Perjury Safeguard: As documented in the attached deficiencies list, the affidavit attached to this inventory shows that the actors deliberately deleted the word "complete" from their verification statement. By replacing it with disclaimers of uncertainty, they rendered the entire inventory legally useless and insulated themselves from perjury.

  4. Total Fiduciary Default: The inventory completely fails to log a dedicated estate trust account. Instead, it references ancient, private bank accounts that remain under private custody, allowing Attorney Ben-Ari to hide the location, volume, and usage of millions of shekels from the lawful heir for over 18 months.

PART III: CHRONOLOGY OF THE INSTITUTIONAL SILENCE

(Cross-Referenced with official Pre-Litigation Notices)

The interaction with the management of the Administrator General reflects an active effort to suppress statutory audit trails:

  • January–October 2025: Inspector Samer Heib transmits the paper copy of the inventory, inadvertently revealing the manual "RECEIVED" stamp and explicitly stating that the file was completely separated from standard automated supervision channels.

  • February 2026: The exact moment Dr. Zernik presented formal questions demanding the identity of the official who authorized this manual paper insertion and the tracking number of the file, the entire administrative apparatus enacted an absolute communications blackout.

  • July 2, 2026: To break the illegal stonewalling, Dr. Zernik served a formal, statutory "Notice of Inspection and Request for Copies" (Bakashat Iyun), under affidavit. The Administrator General's office refused to respond, intentionally violating their statutory obligations under administrative law.

  • July 19, 2026: Following continued statutory default, a formal "Notice of Intent to Initiate Legal Action" (Hatra'a Lifnei Pe'ula Mishpatit) was officially served upon the Administrator General, Ben-Zion Fiegelsohn, and Haifa District Director Tamira Alter.

This prolonged silence is not passive bureaucratic delay; it is a calculated administrative intervention driven by a fear of self-incrimination, designed to protect an off-system, fraudulent operation from formal legal exposure.

 

 

Appendix 10: The Haifa Court is Unable to Collect False Punitive Charges in TE 11650-06-24

Appendix 10: The Haifa Court is Unable to Collect False Punitive Charges in TE 11650-06-24

Appeal to Prof. Uri Sivan, President of the Technion, and Prof. Daniel Chamovitz, Chair of VERA, in re: Review of Rachel Ben-Ari's competence as Legal Counsel

In browser:  https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/appendix-10-haifa-court-is-unable-to.html

The overall claim is that Rachel Ben-Ari is a central figure in a simulated court action in the Haifa Family Court. The simulation of court process is obviously a criminal enterprise, which requires the cooperation of various office holders in the court. 
There is no specific criminal offense of this type in the Israeli penal law. In other places it is specifically defined. For example, Article 32.48 of the Texas Penal Code  - Simulating Legal Process, is short and simple: The elements of the offense include: 1. The production of documents that mimic court records, but have no validity, force and effect. 2. Serving or delivering such documents to others in order that such others will accept them as valid and enforceable court records, and will obey them (e.g., pay money, do or avoid doing certain actions).
As part of the simulation in the Haifa Court, it is alleged that Rachel Ben-Ari is impersonating an Estate Administrator with no lawful appointment. Rachel Ben-Ari has managed to gain control of an Estate of NIS 5-6 million using a paper she drafted and that Judge Hila Gurevitz purportedly signed for her.
Hila Gurevitz, who appears as a Judge in this case (allegedly a simulated judge in a simulated court file), is unhappy with Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik. To show her displeasure, she imposed on him as of July 2026 some NIS 20,000-30,000 in "expenses to benefit the State Treasury". 
Imposing charges of such sums is extreme. Moreover, it is abuse of discretion in the sense that the charges are punitive in nature, but Judge Hila Gurevitz avoids running a punitive procedure, which would require further documentation of her conduct... 
The surprise, at this point, is that Hila Gurevitz is unable to generate charges for collection by the Israeli government Collection Center from this court file... Administrators and IT personnel were consulted, to no avail.
 
A. Imposing the punitive charges as "expenses to benefit the State Treasury" 
.
Event #52, January 20, 2025 -  Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik's repeat Notice of Inspection of Court File
The litigant's right to inspect his court file is a fundamental right. It's denial amounts to denial of access to the court. 
.
Event #52, January 20, 2025 -  Judge Hila Gurevitz's Decision - Denial of the right to inspect, and Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik,is charged  NIS 700 in expenses to benefit the State Treasury.
Since the initiation of the process in this court file, Judge Hila Gurevitz was trying to prevent any record being created in Net HaMishpat of denial of access. In the process, she created rules and regulations that have no foundation in the law. 
 
 
Event #59, March 2, 2025 -- Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik's repeat demand:
That Judge Hila Gurevitz present a reference for her authority in EF 11650-06-24, and 
That Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari and Yoav Salomon cease and desist any action in the Estate until their appointment is duly entered.
 
Event #59, March 3, 2025 --  Judge Hila Gurevitz's Decision 
Judge Gurevitz never provided the requested reference for her assignment in EF 11650-06-24, and charged Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik, NIS 2,500 in expenses to benefit the State Treasury. 
. 
Event #61, March 11, 2025 -- Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik's Request for Clarification, in re: Special registered mail shipments from the Court to Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari
The shipments do not match the schedule of service to other parties in the case. Moreover, Rachel Ben-Ari receives service by email as well. 
 
Event #61, March 13, 2025 -  Judge Hila Gurevitz's Decision
Judge Gurevitz never provided any explanation for the special registered mail shipments to Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari. She issued a special decision, denouncing Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik, and charged him NIS 5,000 in expenses to benefit the State Treasury.
Judge Gurevitz decided to publish her decision in this matter, which did not stop her from keeping the decision title corrupted as usual: Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik was listed first among the parties, as Plaintiff.
 
Event #63, March 16, 2025 - Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik's Notice 

Zernik filed notice with the Court that his false listing as Plaintiff in published records was perceived by him slanderous. All his friends and acquaintances had known his opinion regarding the Family Courts for years. Therefore, official notice listing him as a person that initiated action in a Family Court of the State of Israel was slanderous.

.

B. Inability to generate charges for collection through the Government Collection Center 

1) No Event #, May 25, 2025 Notice by Deputy Clerk Hagit Lasri Ben Hamo

Of note, the Office of the Clerk treated the charges as "Fines", which was legally false. Had Judge Gurevitz imposed charges as "Fines" she would have been compelled to use a different more complex procedure. The charges were strictly imposed as 'expenses,' i.e., reimbursement. Obviously it was a false designation, since the charges were of punitive nature.

 

Translation 

Notice by the Clerk 

Re: Creation of Fine Obligation

In this case, a technical glitch occurred, and it was not possible to update the fines imposed within its framework on Mr. Zernik. (Documentation of Meital’s handling can be viewed in the case notes). Following discussions with the Management representative and the IT representative, we were requested to apply to the Judge and request that a decision be issued ordering the unified collection of the fines and confirming that they are in effect as of this date.

Issued on date 27 Iyar 5785, May 25, 2025. 

Hagit Lasri Ben-Hamo, Department Manager

.

2) No Event #, May 25, 2025 Notice by Judge Hila Gurevitz

 

Translation

25/05/2025 | 27 Iyar 5785   Decision

Case 11650-06-24

Judge Hila Gurevitz Ovadia

The Clerk of the Court announced that due to a technical error, the obligation was not updated upon implementation of the decisions, and the charge was not transferred to the Center for Fine Collection. It was reported that there is a need to give a decision regarding the validity of the previous obligations that were ruled. Accordingly, and per the Secretariat’s request, it is clarified that the charge imposed on Defendant 1 – Mr. Yosef Zernik, in expenses as detailed below, is in force:

  1. Decision dated 20/01/2025 in the amount of 700 NIS; Motion 52

  2. Decision dated 13/03/2025 in the amount of 5,000 NIS; Motion 61

  3. Decision dated 03/04/2025 in the amount of 5,000 NIS; Motions 62, 63.

The Clerk of the Court shall implement and update the charge row accordingly and serve the decision to the parties and the estate administrators.

                                                                         *** Digitally Signed ***

 Note

The inscription at the lower left corner of the yellow "Post-it" Decision reads, "***Digitally signed***". 

The automatic green seal, "True Copy", and below it, the light blue shield with the inscription, "This record is digitally signed." 

There is no "Digital Signature" defined in the Israeli Electronic Signature Law, 2001. Therefore, the inscriptions may refer to some other forms of signature.


3) June 4, 2025, Payment Voucher issued by the Office of the Clerk

 

Translation 

Haifa Family Court

Estate File 11650-06-24               June 4, 2025 

Notice of Charges of Expenses to benefit the State Treasury 

Your payment is demanded:

Type                             Activity                               Total demanded

Expenses to benefit        Formation of a                         NIS 10,700.00

the State Treasury         Fine with no beneficiary

... last date for payment June 24, 2025. A payment that is not paid on time is transferred for collection by the Collection Center.  

.

C. Further charges imposed on Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik 

Event #70, June 30, 2025 - Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik's Request for Clarification, in re: Revocation of autonomous person status
Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik filed a request for clarifications, in re: Judge Hila Gurevitz's decisions to revoke his recognition as an autonomous legal person. 

The two purported decisions—one dated June 25, 2024, and the second from the hearing on October 9, 2024—deviate from the required form for recording decisions due to the absence of a signed written document (even if not strictly required under the Regulations of Civil Procedure 2018, reasoning and service/delivery are required).

Furthermore, they are contrary to the laws of the State of Israel, Article 6 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), and Article 16 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966).

The request also noted that such actions were perpetrated by the courts in the Southern States after the Civil War, as a method to re-enslave the freed slaves. In response, the U.S. Congress enacted between 1865-1870 acts such as "Deprivation of Rights Under the Color of Law" and "Conspiracy against Rights". Such acts were aimed at law and justice officers, and the maximum penalty was Capital Punishment! 

Would Judge Hila Gurevitz clarify whether she considers these two acts valid decisions of the Court? 

  

Event #70, July 6, 2025 - Judge Hila Gurevitz's Decision

 

Gurevitz  imposed a "Blocking Decree" on filing in court by Respondent 1, a charge of NIS 6,000 in "expenses to benefit the State Treasury", and NIS 25,000 Deposit for future expenses.

. 

Event #72, July 23, 2025 -- Request for Instruction by "Estate Administrators" 

The request was entered under Respondent 2, Dror Zernik, since there are no "Estate Administrators" defined in the court file. The request asked permission to pay certain expenses from the Estate funds, and to be exempt from filing further requests for instructions.

Event #72, July 28, 2025 -- Response by Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik

Joseph Zernik's response: The request failed to include an affidavit by the "Estate Administrators" as prescribed by law. Therefore, the request should be summarily dismissed.

Event #72, July 29, 2025, AM --  Decision by Judge Hila Gurevitz

Gurevitz decided that the requested payments were permitted. NIS 1,500 in "expenses to benefit the State Treasury" were imposed on Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik, since his conduct demonstrated lack of trust in the attorneys.

Event #72,  July 29, 2025, ~15:00 -- all papers under Event #72 disappeared.

See further details under Appendix 12: The history of Event #72.   

. 

D. Conclusions 

Judge Hila Gurevitz is allegedly engaged in an extensive plot of Fraud Upon the Court, where Attorney Rachel Ben-Ari is a central figure.

As part of this allegedly criminal plot, there is a need to silence Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik. Imposing still charges was one of the ways that Judge Hila Gurevitz tried to silence him.

As of July 2026, Judge Hila Gurevitz was unable to generate charges from EF 11650-06-24 and transfer them for collection in the government's collection center.

From day one, Respondent 1, Joseph Zernik, claimed that this court action amounts to a simulation, or a fictitious litigation. One of the ways to administer such fictitious action may involve the use of inherently fictitious electronic files in Net HaMishpat. The designation of "Fictitious Files" in Net HaMishpat first appeared in a publication by the Research Department of the Administration of Court in 2011. The reference there was to court files of type TLA [תל"א] and TLP [תל"פ].[1] This issue deserves a separate investigation, since it is an entire level of specifications of court files, which may be critical to the conduct of the process, which is hidden from the public. Yet another reason whey the system must be independently examined by State employees under the appropriate authorizations.

A separate issue that deserves attention is the designation of funds, which are collected by the courts. Judge Hila Gurevitz designated the charges as "expenses to benefit the State Treasury". However, the vouchers that were produced by the Office of the Clerk converted the charges into "fines with no beneficiary." "Expenses" are reimbursement, a clearly non-punitive payment. "Fines" on the other hand are clearly of punitive nature. And with "no beneficiary" it is anybody's guess, where the money ends up.

 

 

 

Appendix 9: October 9, 2024, Event at the Haifa Court

Appendix 9: October 9, 2024, Event at the Haifa Court

Was it a Court Hearing? Was it an off-the-record informal hearing? Was there a Protocol?

Is there a Declarant Order [Psikta]? 

Appeal to Prof. Uri Sivan, President of the Technion, and Prof. Daniel Chamovitz, Chair of VERA, in re: Review of Rachel Ben-Ari's competence as Legal Counsel 


Appendix 8: Invalid Service, and No Service at All

Appendix 8: Invalid Service, and No Service at All

Appeal to Prof. Uri Sivan, President of the Technion, and Prof. Daniel Chamovitz, Chair of VERA, in re: Review of Rachel Ben-Ari's competence as Legal Counsel

 

 

.

 

Appendix 7 | Informal Docket/Register of Actions in Net HaMishpat, where some 25% of the numbered actions are hidden

Appendix 7 | Informal Docket/Register of Actions in Net HaMishpat, where some 25% of the numbered action items are hidden from the litigant

https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/appendix-29.html

Index of Appendices and Biosketch, Joseph Zernik, PhD, LLB

https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/appeal-for-review-of-rachel-ben-aris.html

Rachel Ben-Ari's competence as General Legal Counsel - Appeal Filed with Prof. Uri Sivan, Technion President, and Prof. Daniel Chamovitz, Chair of VERA and Ben Gurion University President

https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/2026-07-17-technion-israel-institute-of.html

In the courts of some nations, the court files include a "Docket" or "Register" that lists the records entered in the court file during the litigation. In some nations, such a Docket or a Register is established by law as the official record of litigation. That is to say, the litigation was based on the records listed in the docket or register. 

  

A Competent Court of Record is a judicial body that possesses proper subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction (competence) over a given cause, whose acts and judicial proceedings are enrolled in an official, permanent record intended to serve as perpetual memory and conclusive evidence of its judgments.

The Israeli courts' CMS (case management system) Net HaMishpat, which was developed "with no representation of the public interest" [State Ombudsman Report 60b, 2010], has no formal Docket or Register of Actions. The system, in general, is short on formal definitions or established rules for its management and maintenance. 

There are several lists of records in a typical Net-HaMishpat court file, e.g., "Paper File," "Entering Records," "Requests and Instructions," "Post-judgment Requests," "Pleadings," "Judgments," etc. Combined, the "Requests and Instructions" and "Post-judgment Requests" are typically treated as an informal Docket or Register of Actions.

Net HaMishpat is also distinguished by the absence of a User's Manual for a system that has been in service for over 15 years and whose development cost has likely surpassed NIS 1 billion (in current currency). The absence of a User's Manual is unlikely to be the result of an oversight or human error. It is more likely related to the need to avoid written definitions and explanations.

For example, a Docket or Register of Actions typically wouldn't list drafts of judicial records, only the signed, valid record. As separately described, Net HaMishpat records are electronic records signed with invisible, undetectable electronic signatures that only judges can detect. At the same time, the electronic signatures presented in Net HaMishpat records are patently invalid (see a separate Appendix).

At the same time, in the absence of rules, judges may execute various transactions in the "Requests and Instructions" and "Post-judgment Requests".

The example below is from Estate File 11650-06-24 in the Haifa Family Court. The figures below show the "Requests and Instructions" and "Post-judgment Requests" - combined, around 25% of the numbered items on the Register of Actions are hidden, not accessible to the litigant.  

The visibility of the numbered items on the Register is not that stable either. Some records may disappear with no notice, request, or decision.

When requests were filed seeking explanations, Judge Hila Gurevitz issued decisions stating that the computer jumped numbers from time to time... She also called upon Deputy Clerk Keren Peles to support that explanation. Eventually, she issued a decision: You see what you are supposed to see.


In Estate File 11650-06-10 in the Haifa Family Court, Hila Gurevitz - Judge,

Adv. Rachel Ben-Ari - Counsel for Respondent (Defendant) 2 and partner with Counsel for Applicant (Plaintiff) in the "joint enterprise" of filing the action court, General Legal Counsel for the Technion and VERA. 

1. Informal Docket/Register of Actions in Net HaMishpat, where some 25% of the numbered action items are hidden from the litigant 

The list below shows screen prints of the informal Docket in Net HaMishpat - "Requests and Instructions" and "Post-judgment Requests" as of May 23, 2026. 

 

Missing: 86, 87, 92.

.


Missing: none.

.

Missing: none.

.

Missing: 79.

.

Missing: none.

. 

Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: 71, 72.

.


Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: 60, 61.

.

 

Missing: 57. 

.


Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: none.

. 


Missing: 39, 40, 41, 42.

.

 

Missing: 35. 

.


Missing: none.

.


Missing: 29.

.

Missing: 22, 23.

.

 

Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: 12, 17.

.

Missing: none.

. 

 

Missing: none.

.

 

Missing: 3, 4, 5, 6.

 

2. Documentation of changes in the Informal Docket, with some records disappearing with no notice, request, or decision, is separately documented.

. 

3. Requests for explanation of the missing numbered items, and Decisions by Judge Hila Gurevitz with help from Deputy Clerk Keren Peles

a) Request #14, dated August 6, 2024, and Decision #14, dated October 30, 2024

 

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

.

 

b)  

 


2026-07-19 הצעה לעו"ד רחל בן-ארי להתפטר ממשרת היועמ"שית לטכניון ולור"ה

 2026-07-19 

הצעה לעו"ד רחל בן-ארי להתפטר ממשרת היועמ"שית לטכניון ולור"ה, 

נשיא הטכניון, פרופ' אורי סיון מתבקש לבדוק את התאמת היועמ"שית לטכניון, עו"ד רחל בן-ארי, להמשך כהונתה בתפקיד

May be an image of ‎text that says '‎למה רפורמה? הילה השופטת הילה גורביץ ועורכת הדין רחל בן-ארי אותות המרמה‎'‎ 

בדפדפן: https://inproperinla.blogspot.com/2026/07/2026-07-19.html 

יוסף צרניק, PhD, LLB, שלח אמש (18.7.2026) לנשיא הטכניון פרופ' אורי סיון, וליו"ר ור"ה [ועד ראשי האונירסיטאות], שהוא נשיא אוניברסיטת בן-גוריון, פרופ' דניאל חיימוביץ', בקשה לבדוק את התאמתה של עו"ד רחל בן-ארי להמשך כהונתה כיועמ"שית לטכניון ולור"ה. יועמ"שית למוסד הממומן מכספי הציבור, כמו הטכניון, אמורה לפקח על חוקיות התנהלותו של המוסד ויושרתו, כולל ענייני ניהול כספים, רכש, מכרזים ופטור ממכרזים. בפנייה לנשיא הטכניון כותב צרניק על מעשיה של רחל בן-ארי בבית המשפט לענייני משפחה, בפרשת עיזבון אמו ז"ל.
היום, צרניק שלח הצעה לרחל בן-ארי, להתפטר מיד מתפקידה כיועמ"שית לטכניון ולור"ה. שכן, המשך כהונתה יכול לגרום נזק לטכניון ולאוניברסיטאות.
כביכול, אין אולי עוד מי שיוכל להתאים לתפקיד יועמ"שית הטכניון כמו רחל בן-ארי. היא הוכשרה לתפקיד עוד מבית אבא...   רחל בן-ארי מפרסמת את עצמה כ"90 שנות מצוינות משפטית", ובכך היא כורכת את עצמה עם פועלם של אביה וסבה. לא ברור מה עמדת אביה וסבה בעניין כריכה זו...
מן המעט שידוע על אביה, יש להניח שהיה אדם ישר. שכן, הוא כיהן כיו"ר ועדת הבחירות הארצית להסתדרות. בד"כ מציבים בעמדה כזאת אדם שיהיה מקובל גם על מפלגות מיעוט ואופוזיציה, כדי לשוות יושרה לבחירות. 
"אינני יכול לומר דבר דומה על רחל בן-ארי" אומר צרניק. את ההודעה ששלח לה היום (העתק להלן) סיכם כך: "שתיקתך הממושכת אינה משנה את הרושם הכללי: את מתנהגת בעניין העיזבון שבנידון כפורעת חוק, חסרת יושרה, המפרה חובת אמונים". 
כבר שנתיים, רחל בן-ארי והילה גורביץ, שופטת משפחה שבן-ארי קידמה את מינויה, עוסקות במרמה לכאורה - הליכי משפט למראית עין. כלומר, הצגה בלבד, כשאין כל תוקף לכתבים להחלטות, לדיונים, לפרוטוקולים...
השניות המדהימה המגולמת ברחל בן-ארי היא מסימני הזמן. 
מצד אחד: "90 שנות מצוינות משפטית", ומדגישה בראיונות לתקשורת את עברם של אביה וסבה כעורכי דין ודמויות ציבוריות. בן-ארי עצמה מוסרת, שסיימה בהצטיינות את לימודי המשפטים באוניברסיטת תל אביב, והיא מצוטטת בתקשורת כמי שמתלוננת על הרמה הנמוכה של עורכי הדין בוגרי המכללות. בן-ארי נבחרה למשרות בכירות בלשכת עורכי הדין, כיהנה שתי קדנציות בוועדה לבחירת שופטים, עמדה בראש הסניף החיפאי של האגודה לזכויות האזרח, היא ממייסדי וחברי מרכז השופט חיים כהן להגנה משפטית על זכויות אדם. בעבר היא כיהנה כיו"ר ועדת הביקורת של הדירקטוריון בחברת החדשות של ערוץ 2. מלבד הטכניון וור"ה, היא מכהנת בשורה של מוסדות חינוכיים ומוסדות עירוניים בחיפה בתפקידים בכירים שונים.
בשיח הציבורי של השנים האחרונות היא גם מופיעה כמתנגדת נחרצת של תוכנית הרפורמה של שר המשפטים יריב לוין. כותרת אחת מדווחת על "שאט נפש מתוכנית הרפורמה", ומצטטת, "הרחוב צריך להשמיע זעקה", בדיווח אחר היא מצולמת כשהיא מובילה מחאת רחוב, ומצוטטת: "אנחנו פה בשם הדמוקרטיה כי רוצים לקחת לנו אותה, וזה הכי מסוכן"... "לוקחים לנו את העצמאות השיפוטית בדרכים שונות...".
מצד שני: כל התיאורים לעיל נשמעים היום כפארסה. בפרט - "העצמאות השיפוטית", שיכולה להתפרש כדרישה להמשך התנאים המאפשרים לה לפעול בצוותא חדא עם השופטת הילה גורביץ מאחורי דלתיים סגורות בענייני עיזבונות...
"אני מכיר אותה עוד מילדותה", אומר יוסף צרניק, PhD, LLB, "אם היא מייצגת אינטרס מנוגד לשלי, יכולים להיווצר חילוקי דעות, זה ברור. אבל יש קו אדום ודגל שחור שמפרידים בין חילוקי דעות לבין המעשים שהיא עושה. היה לי קשה להאמין שהיא תבצע פעולות משפטיות שדגל שחור של עבריינות מתנוסס מעליהן".  
בן-ארי ערכה הסכם חלוקה בין יורשים, ואף התמנתה כנאמנה לביצוע ההסכם, יחד עם שותפה למעשים, עו"ד יואב סלומון, המפרסם את עצמו כ"רב מוניטין". 
אולם בהמשך הם לא ביצעו את ההסכם, והם פועלים בעקביות לסיכולו...
כל זה לא הפריע להם לקחת כל אחד 30,000 ש"ח בתוספת מע"מ מקופת העיזבון באישורה כביכול של השופטת הילה גורביץ, שלא כדרך שמנהלי עיזבון מקבלים את שכרם.